From 46758c97873206dbc17ae75ec8ae0f3f23a863c5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: RCD <90105158+Finesssee@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Sun, 5 Apr 2026 18:44:03 +0700 Subject: [PATCH] chore: record terminal operator scrutiny rerun --- .../fix-runtime-account-count-semantics.json | 21 +++++ .../fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling.json | 28 ++++++ .../scrutiny/synthesis.json | 66 ++++--------- .../scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json | 94 +++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 159 insertions(+), 50 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-runtime-account-count-semantics.json create mode 100644 .factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling.json create mode 100644 .factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json diff --git a/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-runtime-account-count-semantics.json b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-runtime-account-count-semantics.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..43d8b873 --- /dev/null +++ b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-runtime-account-count-semantics.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "featureId": "fix-runtime-account-count-semantics", + "reviewedAt": "2026-04-05T11:36:06.651055Z", + "commitId": "91fe6562", + "transcriptSkeletonReviewed": true, + "diffReviewed": true, + "status": "pass", + "codeReview": { + "summary": "Reviewed the original runtime-stats feature (`1b3542d7`), the prior scrutiny finding, and the fix commit (`91fe6562`). The fix resolves the remaining non-blocking truthfulness issue: `/v0/runtime/stats.account_count` now counts only runtime-usable Codex accounts, mixed-provider and blank-key entries no longer inflate that value, and the TUI wording matches the runtime semantics.", + "issues": [] + }, + "sharedStateObservations": [ + { + "area": "skills", + "observation": "The worker skipped the rust-operator-worker skill's required manual `tuistory` verification even though the feature touched TUI-visible runtime wording. For this fix the unit-level wording assertion was likely sufficient, but the skill currently leaves that lightweight label-only case undocumented.", + "evidence": "Skill procedure step 6 requires manual verification with `tuistory` when the feature affects the TUI or runtime observability surface (`/home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/skills/rust-operator-worker/SKILL.md`). The handoff for session `38bb865f-5bfd-4b20-8a75-281170e69c06` records `followedProcedure: false` and says manual TUI verification was skipped in favor of unit tests because the change was only label alignment." + } + ], + "addressesFailureFrom": "/home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/proxy-runtime-stats-surface.json", + "summary": "Pass. The follow-up fix closes the prior `account_count` truthfulness gap and I found no new code issues in the scoped change." +} diff --git a/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling.json b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7e935e80 --- /dev/null +++ b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling.json @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +{ + "featureId": "fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling", + "reviewedAt": "2026-04-05T11:36:55Z", + "commitId": "67c79b9dc5755305448c33df5cb1d761f150bece", + "transcriptSkeletonReviewed": true, + "diffReviewed": true, + "status": "fail", + "codeReview": { + "summary": "Reviewed the fix commit together with both prior failed reviews (`terminal-tui-operator-console` and `cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs`). The passive-polling blocker is resolved: idle polling now stays on `/healthz` + `/v0/runtime/stats`, and the new regression test proves it no longer calls `/v1/models`. However, the footer visibility blocker is only partially fixed: the panel now fits the four nominal footer lines, but realistic long feedback still wraps and pushes the help text back out of view.", + "issues": [ + { + "file": "rust/proxypilot-rs/src/tui.rs", + "line": 396, + "severity": "blocking", + "description": "The footer still has a fixed height of `Constraint::Length(6)`, which leaves only four inner text rows once the bordered `Keys` block is rendered (`tui.rs:530-543`). That is enough only when the feedback line stays on a single row. But routine operator messages in this same file are much longer\u2014for example the `runtime_refresh_target` failure text at `tui.rs:701-708` is 131 characters before account-name variation, so in the worker's own 120-column verification geometry it wraps to two rows. When that happens, one of the status/help lines is clipped again, so the feature does not fully satisfy the prior blocker of keeping all footer/help guidance visible. The added snapshot test (`tui.rs:943-975`) only exercises a short `Feedback line`, so it misses this realistic wrapped-feedback path." + } + ] + }, + "sharedStateObservations": [ + { + "area": "skills", + "observation": "The shared Rust operator-worker guidance still does not tell workers to exercise long, wrapped operator feedback when validating fixed-height TUI regions. That omission helped this fix reintroduce a footer-visibility edge case even though the worker followed the documented procedure and added a snapshot test.", + "evidence": "`rust-operator-worker` step 6/7 asks for manual TUI verification and truthful operator-visible wording review, but it does not call out wrap/line-budget checks for fixed-height panels (`/home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/skills/rust-operator-worker/SKILL.md`). In this fix, the new regression test in `rust/proxypilot-rs/src/tui.rs:943-975` only uses a one-line `Feedback line`, while the production footer can render much longer routine messages such as `runtime_refresh_target` at `tui.rs:701-708`." + } + ], + "addressesFailureFrom": "/home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/terminal-tui-operator-console.json; /home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/reviews/cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs.json", + "summary": "Fail. The fix successfully stops passive idle polling from contaminating runtime telemetry, but the footer/help blocker is not fully resolved because long, routine feedback messages can still wrap and hide guidance in the fixed-height footer." +} diff --git a/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.json b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.json index f6cfa1f3..a3a66b7c 100644 --- a/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.json +++ b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "milestone": "terminal-operator-console", - "round": 1, + "round": 2, "status": "fail", "validatorsRun": { "format": { @@ -25,70 +25,36 @@ } }, "reviewsSummary": { - "total": 6, - "passed": 4, - "failed": 2, + "total": 2, + "passed": 1, + "failed": 1, "failedFeatures": [ - "terminal-tui-operator-console", - "cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs" + "fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling" ] }, "blockingIssues": [ { - "featureId": "terminal-tui-operator-console", + "featureId": "fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling", "severity": "blocking", - "description": "The TUI footer/help block still uses Constraint::Length(3) while rendering four content lines inside a bordered block, so the selected-account/runtime divergence copy and key help are clipped off-screen. This makes the console fail both the TUI readability contract and the CLI/runtime-truthfulness feature's operator-facing explanation goals." - }, - { - "featureId": "terminal-tui-operator-console", - "severity": "blocking", - "description": "The TUI background polling path still calls GET /v1/models whenever /healthz succeeds, which goes through the proxy and mutates total_proxied_requests, successful_upstream_responses, and potentially last_refresh/auth state. Leaving the console open therefore contaminates the runtime stats it is supposed to observe." - } - ], - "nonBlockingIssues": [ - { - "featureId": "proxy-runtime-stats-surface", - "severity": "non_blocking", - "description": "runtime_stats.account_count currently reports all saved state entries rather than only runtime-usable Codex accounts, so mixed-provider saved state can overstate runtime-usable account count." - } - ], - "appliedUpdates": [ - { - "target": "services.yaml", - "description": "Added `init`, `typecheck`, and `lint` commands so scrutiny/user-testing workers can bootstrap the Rust slice and run the full validator suite from shared service metadata.", - "sourceFeature": "scrutiny-validator-terminal-operator-console" - }, - { - "target": "library", - "description": "Documented in `.factory/library/environment.md` that `./.factory/init.sh` fetches Rust dependencies and creates `rust/proxypilot-rs.toml` when missing before smoke validation.", - "sourceFeature": "shared-auth-runtime-domain" + "description": "The TUI footer still has a fixed six-row outer height, which leaves only four inner text rows inside the bordered keys block. Long routine feedback such as the runtime-active-account failure copy wraps at the validated terminal width, so one of the footer status/help lines becomes clipped again and the operator console still fails the footer-visibility contract." } ], + "nonBlockingIssues": [], + "appliedUpdates": [], "suggestedGuidanceUpdates": [ { "target": "rust-operator-worker", - "suggestion": "Clarify that mission artifacts may live under `/home/fsos/.factory/missions/` even when repo-relative `.factory/missions/...` paths are absent, and instruct workers to fall back to the absolute mission directory before treating missing files as blockers.", - "evidence": "Review reports for `shared-auth-runtime-domain` and `fix-tui-runtime-truthfulness` both recorded ENOENT attempts against repo-relative mission paths before successfully reading `/home/fsos/.factory/missions/7e6968f8-b3d3-4772-9518-ca3a93ea1374/...`.", + "suggestion": "When validating fixed-height TUI regions, explicitly exercise long wrapped operator feedback (not just short placeholder strings) so layout-fit checks prove realistic messages remain visible.", + "evidence": "The follow-up review for `fix-tui-footer-and-passive-polling` found the new snapshot test only covered a short `Feedback line`, while real footer messages in `rust/proxypilot-rs/src/tui.rs` are long enough to wrap and clip help text again within the fixed six-row footer.", "isSystemic": true }, { "target": "rust-operator-worker", - "suggestion": "For TUI features that change visible copy or layout, require a layout-fit visibility check (render/snapshot or terminal smoke) in addition to helper-string assertions so multi-line regions are proven visible.", - "evidence": "Both `terminal-tui-operator-console` and `cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs` failed review because the footer stayed at `Constraint::Length(3)` while rendering four lines, yet the worker tests only asserted helper-string content.", - "isSystemic": true - }, - { - "target": "rust-operator-worker", - "suggestion": "Reinforce the mission boundary that only docs-scoped features may edit `docs/rust-replatform.md` or `README.md`, and direct workers to defer such changes to the explicit docs-alignment feature when possible.", - "evidence": "Review reports for `proxy-runtime-stats-surface` and `terminal-tui-operator-console` both recorded edits to `docs/rust-replatform.md` despite mission AGENTS guidance reserving docs changes for docs-alignment work.", - "isSystemic": true + "suggestion": "Document when label-only TUI/runtime wording changes may use lightweight non-interactive verification instead of full `tuistory` validation, so narrow observability fixes can follow a clear exception path.", + "evidence": "The pass review for `fix-runtime-account-count-semantics` noted the worker intentionally skipped manual `tuistory` verification because the change only aligned runtime/TUI labels, but the current skill does not describe that small-change exception.", + "isSystemic": false } ], - "rejectedObservations": [ - { - "observation": "Add a dedicated mock upstream/refresh service definition to `.factory/services.yaml` for runtime smoke validation.", - "reason": "ambiguous: the reviewed mock servers were scenario-specific one-off fixtures with ad hoc ports and behavior, so a generic shared service entry would risk encoding the wrong workflow. The concrete bootstrap/config discovery gap was handled instead via additive command/library updates." - } - ], - "previousRound": null + "rejectedObservations": [], + "previousRound": "/home/fsos/code-lean/ai-tools/ProxyPilot/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json" } diff --git a/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f6cfa1f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/.factory/validation/terminal-operator-console/scrutiny/synthesis.round1.json @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +{ + "milestone": "terminal-operator-console", + "round": 1, + "status": "fail", + "validatorsRun": { + "format": { + "passed": true, + "command": "cargo fmt --all --manifest-path rust/Cargo.toml -- --check", + "exitCode": 0 + }, + "test": { + "passed": true, + "command": "cargo test --manifest-path rust/Cargo.toml", + "exitCode": 0 + }, + "typecheck": { + "passed": true, + "command": "cargo check --manifest-path rust/Cargo.toml", + "exitCode": 0 + }, + "lint": { + "passed": true, + "command": "cargo clippy --manifest-path rust/Cargo.toml --all-targets -- -D warnings", + "exitCode": 0 + } + }, + "reviewsSummary": { + "total": 6, + "passed": 4, + "failed": 2, + "failedFeatures": [ + "terminal-tui-operator-console", + "cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs" + ] + }, + "blockingIssues": [ + { + "featureId": "terminal-tui-operator-console", + "severity": "blocking", + "description": "The TUI footer/help block still uses Constraint::Length(3) while rendering four content lines inside a bordered block, so the selected-account/runtime divergence copy and key help are clipped off-screen. This makes the console fail both the TUI readability contract and the CLI/runtime-truthfulness feature's operator-facing explanation goals." + }, + { + "featureId": "terminal-tui-operator-console", + "severity": "blocking", + "description": "The TUI background polling path still calls GET /v1/models whenever /healthz succeeds, which goes through the proxy and mutates total_proxied_requests, successful_upstream_responses, and potentially last_refresh/auth state. Leaving the console open therefore contaminates the runtime stats it is supposed to observe." + } + ], + "nonBlockingIssues": [ + { + "featureId": "proxy-runtime-stats-surface", + "severity": "non_blocking", + "description": "runtime_stats.account_count currently reports all saved state entries rather than only runtime-usable Codex accounts, so mixed-provider saved state can overstate runtime-usable account count." + } + ], + "appliedUpdates": [ + { + "target": "services.yaml", + "description": "Added `init`, `typecheck`, and `lint` commands so scrutiny/user-testing workers can bootstrap the Rust slice and run the full validator suite from shared service metadata.", + "sourceFeature": "scrutiny-validator-terminal-operator-console" + }, + { + "target": "library", + "description": "Documented in `.factory/library/environment.md` that `./.factory/init.sh` fetches Rust dependencies and creates `rust/proxypilot-rs.toml` when missing before smoke validation.", + "sourceFeature": "shared-auth-runtime-domain" + } + ], + "suggestedGuidanceUpdates": [ + { + "target": "rust-operator-worker", + "suggestion": "Clarify that mission artifacts may live under `/home/fsos/.factory/missions/` even when repo-relative `.factory/missions/...` paths are absent, and instruct workers to fall back to the absolute mission directory before treating missing files as blockers.", + "evidence": "Review reports for `shared-auth-runtime-domain` and `fix-tui-runtime-truthfulness` both recorded ENOENT attempts against repo-relative mission paths before successfully reading `/home/fsos/.factory/missions/7e6968f8-b3d3-4772-9518-ca3a93ea1374/...`.", + "isSystemic": true + }, + { + "target": "rust-operator-worker", + "suggestion": "For TUI features that change visible copy or layout, require a layout-fit visibility check (render/snapshot or terminal smoke) in addition to helper-string assertions so multi-line regions are proven visible.", + "evidence": "Both `terminal-tui-operator-console` and `cli-state-runtime-truthfulness-and-docs` failed review because the footer stayed at `Constraint::Length(3)` while rendering four lines, yet the worker tests only asserted helper-string content.", + "isSystemic": true + }, + { + "target": "rust-operator-worker", + "suggestion": "Reinforce the mission boundary that only docs-scoped features may edit `docs/rust-replatform.md` or `README.md`, and direct workers to defer such changes to the explicit docs-alignment feature when possible.", + "evidence": "Review reports for `proxy-runtime-stats-surface` and `terminal-tui-operator-console` both recorded edits to `docs/rust-replatform.md` despite mission AGENTS guidance reserving docs changes for docs-alignment work.", + "isSystemic": true + } + ], + "rejectedObservations": [ + { + "observation": "Add a dedicated mock upstream/refresh service definition to `.factory/services.yaml` for runtime smoke validation.", + "reason": "ambiguous: the reviewed mock servers were scenario-specific one-off fixtures with ad hoc ports and behavior, so a generic shared service entry would risk encoding the wrong workflow. The concrete bootstrap/config discovery gap was handled instead via additive command/library updates." + } + ], + "previousRound": null +}